A Myth about Visual Schedules Live On :(

April 30, 2012 by - 2 Comments

A Myth About Visual Schedules Lives On
A- A+
Nooooo, not again.   A myth about visual schedules continues to rear its ugly head in a prAACtical situation (maybe we can reframe it into a learning opportunity??).
Some history- A parent of twin girls with autism (age 15 and two other younger children– yes total 4) stopped by our office to pick up some autism awareness materials yesterday (a super busy mom in so many ways —going out of her way to help our community).  As we were exchanging pleasantries and getting updates on how the girls were doing, we heard something that continues to surprise us–(and not in a good way).  What did we hear?
We heard that the girls were doing relatively well (not the surprising comment) but that mom was extra busy because the girls were no longer independent in taking their showers.   They could do it by themselves but didn’t like the sensory input of soap on their bodies and shampoo on their hair, so she had to be in the bathroom to prompt them. She had even created some really cool schedules (including using motivating pictures of ‘cool guys washing their hair’ and ‘cool girls using soap’.  These had worked really well but….. get ready here it comes….she had to stop using them because her autism ‘professional’ (and we use the term very loosely) told her to stop.  When the words “no… no… no”… stopped coming out of our mouths and we got up from the proverbial floor, and we asked what was the rationale that this ‘professional’ gave for this recommendation……and we heard the dreaded “the schedule will become a crutch and make the girls dependent.”

So in what universe is having mom sit near each and every shower creating independence???  What are two AAC girls (woman) to do? “Ahhhhh, Ahhhhh, and ahhhhh”.  We are not sure.. but this is what we did.

  • Informed  her she was given incorrect, unsubstantiated professional information (check out the National Standards Project for Schedules as an Established Treatment)to begin to use the schedules again….immediately
  • got the number of the ‘professional’ who gave the recommendation (Part 2 of this post will contain the outcome of that conversation)
  •  gave mom a list of all the ‘schedules’ EVERYONE uses,  so she would understand and defend her USE of schedules and lists for facilitating independence in her family: day planners, shopping lists, errand schedules, calendars, agendas, trip schedules, etc…
  • gave mom some schedule making resources so she could easily make more schedules for her girls and get them INDEPENDENT on many more activities (these are very capable fun-loving girls)  And so the purpose of this post is not just to rant, but to help everyone who needs schedules get them, check out the resources below.
 Rationales for using Schedules to Create Independence


Please let us know how you combat AAC system myths….


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed under:

Tagged With: , , ,

This post was written by Robin Parker


  • Brooke says:

    Thank GOD you were around when she came in…this is devastatingly sad! WOW…I’m reposting just in case other families out there are of similar misinformed status!!!

    • Robin Parker says:

      Thanks so much for the comment. Sometime it is easy to feel like maybe you have just gone crazy. I actually told mom to try and get by for a day without her schedules and then she really seemed to understand. Thanks for reposting. Maybe if more people who were not sure about visual supports will learn that they increase independence and to use schedules and mini schedules more often.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.